Two winners selected for new Rochester flag

Does this scream, “Rochester, Minn.,” to you? It’s the winner in the public voting to replace the city’s official flag.

Joe Uessem, of Germany, designed it. He’s never been to Rochester, he said in his design statement.

‘I, myself, am not from the city. My girlfriend though can’t stop talking about her old home. The misfortune that burnt down her family’s house and the possibility to start over again in Rochester are the most defining points of her life. The support that her family got from the good citizens of Rochester gave her strength to not lose hope.

Hope, Support, Love: this is what the City of Rochester stands for and what I want to show in my flag design. The design consists of three colors: The silver (white) lining separates the green ground (Which traditionally stands for hope.) and the blue sky (Blue stands for happiness and serenity.). The white goose does not only stand out on the darker background, it also flies towards freedom which the viewer expects out of the flag’s boundaries. Geese and Rochester have a special connection, and whenever I see a Canada goose, I think of the city. I am sure that many people feel the same way about
those beautiful animals.’

The winner in the judges’ category lives in Rochester, just not that Rochester. Matt Levar is from Rochester, NY.

His statement:

This is a modern adaption of Rochester’s current flag, with the overt visuals replaced with meaningful symbols of the city’s Past, Present, and Future. Here, a gold ring encompasses the city, symbolizing the community’s unity and values. Inside, three stars, one for the city’s founding (lower left), one for the great tornado and the medical community that came from it (lower right), and the highest one for the city’s future. The stars shine in a night sky over the city’s South Fork Zumbro and Bear Creek Rivers.

There have been two contest rounds so far in the effort to replace the current design, which is considered outdated.

Fifty-five flag designs were submitted.

The closest a Rochester resident got to winning the competition was third-place tie in the judges category by Donald Buske.

“Rochester is an internationally recognized city and it needs symbols that reflect its unique place in the world,” Lee Herold, of Herold Flags, said in a news release. “Drab and boring will not do. I would also say that almost all of the contest entries were well-designed and creative and would make excellent flags. It was difficult to choose the very best.”

It’s up to the Rochester City Council to select a winner.

  • MrE85
  • Leroy

    Having grown up in Rochester years ago the flag with the goose clearly says Rochester. I hope they go with that one rather than the others which could easily fly on a flagpole on any city.

  • Erik Petersen

    I like the one with the sky carp on it

    • Tyler

      I think you mean cobra chicken.

      • Erik Petersen

        great expression, hadn’t heard it before

  • boB from WA

    “…whenever I see a Canada goose, I think of the city.” – Whenever I see a Canada goose (or any goose for that matter), I think of their habit of leaving a part of themselves behind (and not the good parts).

  • Gary F

    All the defecating menances at Silver Lake and they want that on their flag?

    • Rob

      My first thought as well. Rochester: Come for the health care, stay for the goose poop.

    • Brian Simon

      “Defecating menaces.” I think even out of context we’d know exactly what you’re talking about.

  • Rob

    Facepalm

  • Nato Coles

    Change the font (yeesh, talk about outdated – a city flag that uses the TI-82 font*?), and with a few tweaks, the original flag is ten times better than any of the three newer proposals.

    *ok, I’m not entirely sure what that font is but it’s pretty “mid-80’s futuristic”

    • Jack Ungerleider

      My first thought was “that’s an OCR font!” A quick search via the Google reveals it is “Data 70”.
      http://www.identifont.com/find?font=data+70&q=Go

    • Jerry

      Considering IBMs abandonment of the city, the computer inspired font probably needs to go.

      • Rory Kramer

        IBM still has a presence in Rochester. The down-scaling of operations in Rochester is typical of the rest of the computer/technology industry-don’t need as many workers as before with the need to consolidate operations to be more cost-efficient. Basic Economics 101.

        • Jerry

          It’s not really blaming IBM. It’s more pointing out that Rochester is no longer a 2 company town. It’s pretty much just Mayo.

  • X.A. Smith

    To me, the German entry seems the most Minnesotan.

  • Jack Ungerleider

    Go with the people’s choice. If you’re going to make a change, make a change. Don’t go with the overly simplified abstract version of the current flag.

    The one from the person in Rochester made me think Puerto Rico, Cuba, and Texas.

  • Jerry

    “those beautiful animals”

    Yes, that’s what I think of when I think of geese. Not “honk HONK HONK honk honk HONK HONK HONK honk”