Big Grass has won again.
In St. Peters, Mo., a couple could go to jail for refusing to plant grass in their front yard.
Jan Duffner pulled her front yard out because she’s allergic to grass. She planted wildflowers and a garden instead.
But nothing — except for, perhaps, a hockey rink — can stir up neighbors like someone who challenges the norms of the front yard lawn.
The city has a grass turf ordinance requiring homeowners to plant lawns, so the Duffners sued in federal court, claiming the law “imposes a permanent obligation on the owner to cultivate and maintain that unwanted physical presence on their property for no reason other than that the government commands it.”
On Thursday, a judge threw the case out, according to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.
Judge John Ross said “aesthetic considerations constitute a legitimate government purpose.”
Dave Roland, a Freedom Center of Missouri lawyer representing the Duffners, says he’ll appeal the ruling.
“If a city can compel citizens to devote half of their property to growing a plant that the citizen does not want and that makes them sick, there is no longer any principled limit to the government’s control over private property,” he said in a statement.
The Duffners say they face jail time or fines of $7,490 to nearly $188,000.