Lutsen bill pits anglers against alpine skiers

A proposal before the Minnesota Legislature would allow Lutsen Mountains ski resort to bypass Department of Natural Resource regulations and pump two million gallons of water per day from the Poplar River. A company official says it’s the most economically feasible way to make artificial snow, but anglers say it threatens trout on the river. Environmentalists suggest pumping the water from Lake Superior, a suggestion Lutsen rejects as too costly.

The Senate Finance Committee will entertain the proposal this week according to the Duluth News Tribune.

Steve Persons, DNR area fisheries supervisor in Grand Marais, said river freeze-out during low water in winter months, called anchor ice, could hurt the river’s populations of brook trout, rainbow trout, salmon and “coaster” brook trout that migrate into the river from Lake Superior.

“Allowing large appropriations of water during a low-flow period could increase the severity and frequency of anchor ice, and that certainly limits habitat for fish and the ecosystem they depend on,” Persons said.

He said the effects of past water use to make snow at Lutsen is unclear.

“We don’t have this situation with any other trout stream because it’s something we don’t allow,” Persons said.

Even without passage of the bill, Senate File 1244, Lutsen has circumvented DNR regulations for years according the the News Tribune.

Lutsen Mountains Corp. began violating the permit in 2001, pumping between 60 and 107 million gallons each snowmaking season since. While DNR officials have known about the violations since 2002, the agency has taken no action against the company.

John Lenczewski, executive director of Minnesota Trout Unlimited wrote on his organizations blog that Lutsen Mountain Corporation’s “excessive water withdrawals from the Poplar River since 2001 are outside the permit. This conduct should not be rewarded with a special exemption permitting it to destroy a public resource.”


Also clicking on MN Today

A mostly civil debate on guns? Yep. See it to believe it on Insight Now. Day three on the proposed expansion of the Castle Law. Have your say.

St. Paul schools see $25M shortfall if Legislature’s cuts enacted

The school board faces the prospect of laying off about 300 employees and shelving programs, administrators said. If a measure in the House passes, the cuts will be even deeper, they said (Star Tribune).

Education bill could hit rural school districts hard

Measure would cut sparsity and compensatory aid, which assist rural districts and those with many special needs students (Timberjay).

School lunch prices to rise

Students at one local school will have to fork over more money for lunch.Austin Public Schools voted last night to raise the prices of lunch and breakfast starting next year (KIMT).

Books

A review by MN Today contributor Ann Klefstad

A beautiful biography of a late-flowering life

Poet Molly Peacock lovingly channels her kindred spirit, Mary Delany, in this charming biography of the 18th-century botanical artist (Star Tribune).

Blog Box

Eden Prairie students pledge allegiance en Español. As a Spanish minor — with two Kindergartners learning the language, albeit not via immersion — nobody can accuse me of lack of appreciation for good old Español. But in six years of study, there’s one thing I never learned to say in Spanish — the Pledge of Allegiance (The Activist Next Door).

Minnesota Scenes

Wild Tulips

  • highpockets

    Tthe headline of this story is misleading – skiers and anglers can co-exist just fine. The issue is that the ower of the ski resort doesn’t want to shell out $$$ to get water from a far more sustainable source, and is looking for an exception to state law to allow this ongoing violation.